followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Fit To Print

Newspapers Trim Newsprint Usage So Newsprint Producers Cut Production And In This Classic Case of Supply And Demand It Looks Like Price Increases Up To 30% May Stick this Year

Usually when advertising takes a downturn newspaper suppliers are understanding and hold their price line, they may even reduce pricing a bit. So now that newspapers are going through one of the worst advertising cutbacks ever, what do the newsprint producers do? Why, naturally, they’re piling on big price increases backed by a drop in supply leaving publishers squirming between a rock and a hard place.

newsprintIf ever there was a love-hate marriage within an industry it has to be newspapers and their newsprint suppliers. Look at a graph of newsprint pricing over the past 20 years and it is one of huge mountains and deep valleys. There has been very little price stability, one side always looking for the weakness in the other to get a better deal. In years gone by newspapers saw newsprint producers as the villains attacking very lucrative margins, but today it is far more serious as those margins seriously dwindle. 

Just look at the pricing over the past 12 years or so. In 1996 newsprint hit a high of $750 with some publishers then said to have paid closer to $900 fearful the price would go higher. This was a wakeup call and publishers then started the process of seriously reducing the news hole, narrowing column widths and the like – what is being done today is not new, it is a continuation of old tried policies. Publishers at that time also started saying out loud that maybe there should be some sort of price stability pact between newsprint producers and publishers.

But no sooner was that being talked about than the price started softening and in proportional ratio so did publisher talk of price stability. Within six years newsprint prices had sunk to $425/tonne and it was the producers talking out loud about having some sort of price stability.

About a year ago the price was around $570 - $575, close to the median. Peter Appert, then media analyst at Goldman Sachs explained, “Our sense is that both publishers and newsprint producers would like to see greater stability in newsprint prices, but neither side knows how to achieve this goal. For publishers, the tug-of-war between the greater long-term cost viability through more stable prices versus the short-term earnings benefit of cyclical depressed paper prices always seems to favor short-term earnings.”

And Wednesday Goldman Sachs’ Paper and Forest Products research team, including Appert, came to the conclusion that for now at least the producers, by cutting back supply as much as they have, are now winning the day in spite of everything newspapers have been doing to reduce newsprint consumption. Their pricing conclusion – by the end of this year prices will have jumped 30%. And this is not so short-term – they predict high pricing will continue through all of 2009.

AbitibiBowater CEO David Paterson said at his company’s annual meeting last month that he expected North American demand for newsprint to drop some 8 – 10% this year, similar to last year’s percentage drop, but even with that usage reduction producers are pushing through $20 a tonne increase this month and also in August that will bring prices to around the $750 mark -- pricing most analysts seem to believe will stick and publishers by their actions seem to agree, too. The big question then becomes what can the producers get away with in the fourth quarter, and the belief is prices will end the year not far from the $790 mark.  Compare that to the $590 a tonne paid during 2007’s deepest valley!

The bottom line, according to AbitibiBowater’s Paterson, “We've just got to make our newsprint business profitable ... or it'll just go out of business." And it’s not that he is being greedy, his company announced a first-quarter loss of $215 million or $3.74 a share on sales totaling $1.7 billion. The company said US newsprint losses were reduced only slightly and there will be more mill conversions to higher-grade, higher profit paper.

Seen from a publisher or editor’s viewpoint, however, the situation is quite different. Dale Bryant of Silicon Valley (yes, that Silicon Valley) Community Newspapers wrote, “Even in a difficult economy, the tides have been mostly calm and mostly predictable. What we didn't count on was a rogue wave out of nowhere that nearly knocked us off our feet.  That wave is the manifestation of soaring newsprint costs…  In response to rising costs, newspapers have cut back on the use of newsprint, trimming the size of papers as well as turning to the Internet. That has caused prices to go even higher.”

So it’s no wonder that just this week, for instance, the Review Atlas in Monmouth, Illinois, announced it was abolishing its Monday paper and would now publish Tuesday – Saturday. The publisher blamed rising newsprint costs (up 45% in just 12 months) and declining ad revenue (down 12.9% from last year). . It is the second Gatehouse Media newspaper in Illinois to make that decision.

And there seems to be a trend across the US that if the Monday newspaper doesn’t disappear then at least the Monday and Tuesday editions are having their pages cut way back.

Other newspapers continue page size reductions. The Tyler Morning Telegraph (Texas) said it expected a $600,000 increase in newsprint costs so it was trimming its page size hoping to save around 25% of that extra cost.  Publisher Nelson Clyde IV said, “Reducing the width of the newspaper is an evolving trend taking place at newspapers across the country.”

Many newspapers seem to be attacking free-standing business sections; it’s not enough that share price listings have been mostly banished to the Internet, now business news is being pared way back, partly because advertisers for some reason seem to shy away from those pages.

Just how much more can publishers cut back? The Pulp and Paper Council’s May report said US newspaper newsprint consumption was down 16% from a year earlier and that for the first five months of the year consumption was down 14%. Yet for all that the law of supply (mills operating at about 90% of capacity) and demand (full year decline expected to be at least 10%) indicates that the upper hand is with the suppliers, and getting stronger.

Oh, and if newsprint price hikes aren’t enough, Flint Ink has announced a surcharge on news inks because of what it calls “rapidly escalating raw material, energy and freight costs.” The surcharge is in addition to recent price increases.

When it rains, it pours!


related ftm articles

As AbitibiBowater, North America’s Largest Newsprint Producer, Fights To Avoid Becoming Another Bear Stearns, Norway’s Norske Skog Announces More Cutbacks, US Newspaper Groups Brag At Huge Newsprint Usage Declines, And China Ramps up Newsprint Production and Exports
The merger of Abitibi and Bowater last October was supposed to form North America’s largest newsprint producer that could, with the cost savings a merger between two such giants should produce, finally get the upper hand on production and pricing. Instead its shares are down nearly 70% so far this year, off 15% alone on Monday because the markets don’t think its recently announced $1.4 billion refinancing plan will fly.

Norske Plans A Big Newsprint Production Cut In Europe and AbitibiBowater Announces Huge Cuts in North America And There’s Consolidation Galore -- The Perfect Recipe For Higher Newsprint Prices
One saving grace for North American newspapers is that newsprint pricing actually dipped in 2007 but those days are now over. Price increases have already been announced and production is being cut on both sides of the Atlantic.

With China Expected To Deliver 75,000 Tons of Newsprint to the US in 2007, and With Economies Having Already Cut US Newsprint Usage By 6.6% This Year, The Laws Of Supply And Demand Are Finally Favoring Publishers
The relationship between newspapers and their newsprint suppliers has never been a love affair. No matter what publishers did in the past to cut back on their newsprint usage to save costs the producers would go and close down a newsprint paper mill or two to reduce supply and the laws of supply and demand put publishers right back where they were. But this year is different.


advertisement

ftm resources

no resources posted as of July 3, 2008


ftm Knowledge

Media in Spain - Diverse and Challenged – new

Media in Spain is steeped in tradition. yet challenged by diversity. Publishers hold great influence, broadcasters competing. New media has been slow to rise and business models for all are under stress. Rich in language and culture, Spain's media is reaching into the future and finding more than expected. 123 pages, PDF. January 2018

Order here

The Campaign Is On - Elections and Media

Elections campaigns are big media events. Candidates and issues are presented, analyzed and criticized in broadcast and print. Media is now more of a participant in elections than ever. This ftm Knowledge file reports on news coverage, advertising, endorsements and their effect on democracy at work. 84 pages. PDF (September 2017)

Order here

Fake News, Hate Speech and Propaganda

The institutional threat of fake news, hate speech and propaganda is testing the mettle of those who toil in news media. Those three related evils are not new, by any means, but taken together have put the truth and those reporting it on the back foot. Words matter. This ftm Knowledge file explores that light. 48 pages, PDF (March 2017)

Order here

More ftm Knowledge files here

Become an ftm Individual or Corporate Member to order Knowledge Files at no charge. JOIN HERE!


ftm followup & comments

no followup as of July 3, 2008

no comments as of July 3, 2008

Post your comment here

copyright ©2004-2008 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm