followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Fit To Print

Here’s What Print Execs Are Saying About Doom And Gloom

The bad news from Dean Singleton – “We are selling the Connecticut Post to Hearst and paying down a lot of debt.” The good news from Hearst CEO Frank Bennack, Jr’s response, “Newspapers will be viable as far as the eye can see.”

newspaperSingleton and Joseph Lodovic, Media News President, told employees in a company e-mail update, “Proceeds from the sale were used to repay almost 25% of our outstanding bank debt. Secondly, the transaction provides a unique opportunity to approach our bank lenders with a ‘win-win’ proposition. In exchange for the large repayment, our banks agreed to relax certain key aspects of our credit agreement to provide more room to navigate over the coming years. In sum, the sale, coupled with the changes to our credit agreement, provide us the runway we need to execute our strategic plans, position the Company to be opportunistic, and to continue to lead the industry into the future.”

The really good news in the transaction is that Hearst is still a buyer of newspapers while practically everyone else is begging off. And Bennack put the reason why Hearst remains in the newspaper business in non-financial terms. “Newspapers play a vital role in American society. We are not about to give up on that. Who will watch city hall?”

Singleton’s viewpoint: “The newspaper industry has gone through some tough times. We believe the future of newspapering is bright, but the transition will continue to be painful.”

And nowhere is it more painful than at the Tribune newspapers that are all cutting back staffing and redesigning for far fewer pages. But Tribune CEO Randy Michaels, when asked by a Chicago Tribune staffer “Should we be mourning what we’re losing at The Tribune”, responded that “We should grieve for those who have been downsized. We should not be mourning the loss of anything else. Everything has its time. Do we want to look like the Tribune of June 10, 1847? How about 1900? 1910? 1970? This paper has changed with the times, and must continue to do so. We cannot stop change, so the only brave thing to do is lead it.”

Lee Abrams, Tribune’s chief innovation officer, continued, “I think it would be more appropriate to mourn the loss of readership and the reality that newspapers are not as relevant anymore. But I think a more realistic approach is to accept the reality and fight hard to correct the problems facing the medium. It’s not the values at stake; it’s the failure to accept that those values cannot impact the public unless their delivery is re-evaluated to connect with today’s media.”

And when asked if there was a need for introspection Michaels responded, “Introspection is a wonderful thing. Self-indulgence is not. We are in tough times. Many are saying that we won’t make it, but don’t make plans to sit Shiva (in Judaism, a week-long mourning period) for us. We are going to prove them wrong. We have a great history and we should study it, but we can’t turn back the clock or live in the past. The most important part of the history of The Tribune is the one we are going to create. We have the opportunity to make it the best yet.”

Abrams in one of his weekly blogs asked himself the question many publishers are asking themselves these days –“How will newspapers evolve in order to survive?” His response, “By aggressively addressing the problems, throwing out the rule book, liberating ourselves from the past, parking denial at the door, regrouping and doing anything and everything, regardless of how painful. Dramatic problems require dramatic solutions.”

As ftm has often written it is the metropolitan newspapers that are in the most trouble and when you get down to the smaller community newspapers that are truly local in outlook – editorial and advertising – then things don’t seem near as bad. And maybe it’s a lesson the metros could learn from. Paul Davis, publisher of the weekly Tuskegee News in Alabama explained, “Community newspapers are doing quite nicely, thank you, because they have not forgotten their mission, their responsibility to their readers, the service they must provide to their advertisers, their duty to report the good and the bad; to expose corrupt public servants who betray the public trust and seek to serve themselves first at the expense of the taxpayers.”

That sounds very idealistic and there is much that can be argued. Metros, for instance, have more competition, metros have always relied on heavy classified advertising while community newspapers don’t, and with a lot of community newspapers it is somewhat questionable editorially whether most of them really do bite the various hands that feed them. But it sounds nice, anyway.

In Florida the Ledger in Lakeland had to announce an 11% cull and this is how publisher Jerome Ferson explained his situation, “This is a very dynamic time we are in. I would characterize it as a struggle of epic proportions.”

So if there is a difference between the columnists and the bloggers and the like it seems to be the bloggers believe “the end is near” whereas many publishers are saying, “We’re going to have to change a whole lot to keep going.”

 Perhaps the best wrap on the situation comes from Abrams of Tribune: “Bob Dylan’s ‘The Times They Are A Changin’ is to me a timeless message that applies to the era we are in very well.” But will Changin’ Times come soon enough to save the patient?

 

 


related ftm articles

Forget Gannett, Forget McClatchy — Want To Read Positive Stories About The US Newspaper Business Then Concentrate on Community Newspapers – They’re Being Read By 83% of All Americans 18 And Older
While media stories concentrate on the dismal January performances by daily metropolitan newspapers at such big chains as Gannett and McClatchy, there’s actually a section of the US newspaper industry that is continuing to do very well, thank you very much -- non daily community newspapers.

It’s Time To Shoot The Messenger: 'What Is The Purpose, What Do You Hope To Gain' From Your Newspaper Doom And Gloom Articles?
It’s not easy these days writing positive articles about the newspaper industry, and a regular reader has taken this writer to task for newspaper bashing. “Publishers completely understand the challenges before them, but that doom and gloom really goes in one ear and out the other.” the reader chastised.

Did You Know That Newspapers Are a $180 billion Global Industry With More Advertising Revenues Than Radio, Outdoor, Cinema, Magazines And The Internet Combined? Maybe They’re Not Dead After All!
The World Association of Newspapers (WAN) hasn’t much patience with the doom and gloom pundits who constantly report that newspapers are a dying industry, so this week it has produced some updated statistics to show the good news that newspaper circulation globally is growing and new newspapers are being launched far more frequently than may have been thought.


advertisement

ftm resources

no resources posted as of August 13, 2008


ftm Knowledge

Media in Spain - Diverse and Challenged – new

Media in Spain is steeped in tradition. yet challenged by diversity. Publishers hold great influence, broadcasters competing. New media has been slow to rise and business models for all are under stress. Rich in language and culture, Spain's media is reaching into the future and finding more than expected. 123 pages, PDF. January 2018

Order here

The Campaign Is On - Elections and Media

Elections campaigns are big media events. Candidates and issues are presented, analyzed and criticized in broadcast and print. Media is now more of a participant in elections than ever. This ftm Knowledge file reports on news coverage, advertising, endorsements and their effect on democracy at work. 84 pages. PDF (September 2017)

Order here

Fake News, Hate Speech and Propaganda

The institutional threat of fake news, hate speech and propaganda is testing the mettle of those who toil in news media. Those three related evils are not new, by any means, but taken together have put the truth and those reporting it on the back foot. Words matter. This ftm Knowledge file explores that light. 48 pages, PDF (March 2017)

Order here

More ftm Knowledge files here

Become an ftm Individual or Corporate Member to order Knowledge Files at no charge. JOIN HERE!


ftm followup & comments

no followup as of August 13, 2008

no comments as of August 13, 2008

Post your comment here

copyright ©2004-2008 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm