followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Media Rules and Rulers
ftm newsletter

ftm newsletters update leading media news Monday through Friday.
Click here and you will receive it in your inbox.

AGENDA

All Things Digital
This digital environment

Big Business
Media companies and their world

Brands
Brands and branding, modern and post

The Commonweal
Media associations and institutes

Conflict Zones
Media making a difference

Fit To Print
The Printed Word and the Publishing World

Lingua Franca
Culture and language

Media Rules and Rulers
Media politics

The Numbers
Watching, listening and reading

The Public Service
Public Service Broadcasting

Show Business
Entertainment and entertainers

Sports and Media
Rights, cameras and action

Spots and Space
The Advertising Business

Write On
Journalism with a big J

Send ftm Your News!!
news@followthemedia.com

Political Shift to Impact American Broadcasting

As the political wind changes in Washington DC so might the domestic “industry” and US government international broadcasting. Further de-regulation, in particular cross-media ownership, will grind to a halt. US media analysts, largely of the Wall Street variety, see an ominous shift away from the staunchly partisan, pro-big business US Congress.

perfect stormUS commercial broadcasting refers to itself as an “industry.”  Nearly two decades after rolling back nearly all regulation, the industry is facing the prospect of not only an end to further de-regulation but, possibly, old rules returning. All of this is taking place as US broadcasting tries to find its sea-legs during a tidal wave of advertising revenue shifting to new media and a business cycle model hit by a cyclone. Taken in total it might just be the perfect storm that either sinks a business in the decline phase or floats radical changes.

American broadcasting is less and less about enticing viewers and listeners with compelling programming and more and more about value perceived by the investor class. Share prices trump audience figures. Success is measured by the buy-out value and US broadcasting has long been a transaction business.

ftm background

The real “F” Words in US Television Programming Today Are Fear And FCC
It all seems too silly to be true – that in the land of free speech, television stations quiver in case a curse word or two uttered on air during a news documentary covering the 9/11 tragedy will cost those network affiliates hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines.

Dramatic License: Between Docudrama and Reality
The Path to 9/11 docudrama produced for US network ABC panders to the political. It's what we call propaganda.

Pattiz Era Ends at BBG
Norman J. Pattiz has resigned from the Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG), the oversight board which controls American government international broadcasting. His five-year tenure at BBG was fraught with controversy over new radio and television services targeting the Middle East.

US Broadcasting Agencies Under Investigation
After meeting for three days at an undisclosed location the US Corporation for Public Broadcasting board accepted the resignation of former chairman and current board member Kenneth Y. Tomlinson. This week Tomlinson will appear before a Congressional subcommittee investigating Arabic television channel Al-Hurra.

A Cartoon Rabbit Visits Two Lesbian Families and Soldiers Actually Swear In A Documentary about Iraq -- It’s All Too Much for US Public Broadcasting and They’re Looking for a New PBS Boss
With the House of Representatives approving a bill in record time to increase indecency fines from $$32,500 to $500,000, the US Secretary of Education demanding a refund of the department’s funding for a cartoon show...

Clear Channel Communications’ recent announcement that it is entertaining offers from private equity funds came not from anxiety over regulation, even though the company has paid a fortune in indecency fines. Nor did NBC’s announcement that it’s dropping prime time drama for less expensive programming. The market place, fair or not, rules and the investor market sees break-up value and values cost cutting.

Some Congressional Democrats have gone on record as favoring a return, in some sense, of the Fairness Doctrine. When this rule was scuttled in 1988 broadcasters were no longer obligated to provide “equal time” to opposing views. This led to a pandemic of right-wing radio talk shows and, of course, Fox News. Radio stations on the AM band were certainly spared extinction but the level of public discourse inside the US fell to painful depths.

Arguments against the Fairness Doctrine are compelling. Advanced nearly 100 years ago when air-waves were thought to be scarce, the digital age renders that point moot.  “The Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press,” says the First Amendment to the US Constitution, allowing newspapers to tout their owners’ views and endorse political candidates. Broadcasters were unable to dip their toes into controversial positions without raising the certainty of legal action.

Eliminating the Fairness Doctrine and its related rules (i.e. equal time) brought freedom of speech to broadcasters but only in so far as that “speech” could survive in a marketplace. Political attack ads have become common fare throughout US rule by the President’s political party advisors, notably White House advisor Karl Rove. Post election polling indicates the American electorate voted against the “sleaze.”

With the executive and legislative branches of the US government separated by political party Senate and House of Representatives committee chairmanships and memberships, soon to change, will have amore direct effect on policies. The President nominates members and chairman of executive branch agencies - like the FCC – but House and Senate committees have the joy of picking them apart. Another political casualty is likely FCC Chairman Kevin Martin.

Changes at the Senate Commerce Committee, overseer of the FCC, will raise further the industry’s anxiety. Chairmanship will likely go to Hawaii Senator Daniel Inouye, consistently pro-business. But deeper in the loss of Virginia Senator George Allen and Montana Senator Conrad Burns, heavily supported by the National Association of Broadcasters, and the elevation of North Dakota Senator Byron Dorgan within the committee will cause heart-burn among those seeking further loosening of ownership rules.

Outgoing Chairman Alaska Senator Ted Steven’s Telecom Reform bill allowing national video franchising will see neither a committee vote nor the full Senate.

For US public television and radio, political tests will likely end. Republican political operative Kenneth Y. Tomlinson, a Karl Rove ally, was forced out as Public Broadcasting System (PBS) chairman after meandering into political waters, illegally hiring another political operative to report “liberal bias in PBS programming.”

Over at the Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG), where the same Mr. Tomlinson ran his horse racing business from the Chairman’s office, the Senate Foreign Relations Committee has refused to bring forward Tomlinson’s reconfirmation hearings. With the chairmanship of that committee like to be in the hands of Delaware Senator Joseph Biden in January President Bush will need to either give Tomlinson what is called a “recess confirmation” – essentially avoiding the oversight committees – or withdraw the nomination altogether. Controversial UN Ambassador John Bolton received a recess confirmation last year when it became clear that even senators in the President’s party wouldn’t support open confirmation. Senator Biden was a supporter of BBG member Norman Pattiz who often clashed with Tomlinson and resigned last year.

The BBG oversees all US government international broadcasting. Public diplomacy observers have noted the shift of BBG resources away from Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty broadcasting, for example, and toward specialized services that may or may not be effective.


ftm Follow Up & Comments

copyright ©2004-2006 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm