followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Write On

The Soup That Is Censorship

New media has taken its place as rabble rouser-in-chief. Torrents of tiny text can literally light up the sky. Even where censors try to pull the shades, people stay one line – or character – ahead. Anyway, it’s all very good for business.

Chinese SoupChina’s censorship culture felt the crush of protest, live and microblogging, after a local propaganda minister ordered a newspaper to drop a pro-reform New Year’s editorial for something more fluffy.  Staffers at the Southern Weekly went out on strike, which ignited protests in China complete with social media outrage and the widespread attention of Western media. Pro-democracy demonstrators and old-line Communists hurled rants at each other outside the newspaper’s offices until local police chased them off.

The Southern Weekly returned to newsstands last Thursday in Beijing and Shanghai but, according to Reuters (January 10), not widely in Guangzhou where it’s based. Guangdong Communist Party Secretary Hu Chunhua personally intervened, reported shanghaiist.com (January 9). Newspapers staffers were ordered not to talk to foreign media and not to complain publicly about Guangdong propaganda minister Tuo Zhen.

Mr. Hu is new to the job, appointed in December as the Communist Party reshuffled leadership positions following the elevation of Xi Jinping as national party chairman. Last November Mr. Hu became one of the youngest members of the Communist Party Politburo. Mr. Tuo became chief censor in Guangdong Province last May after serving as vice president of state news agency Xinhua. The clampdown on Southern Weekly, often described as a progressive voice, began on Mr. Tuo’s arrival.

Other Chinese newspaper editors and reporters got in their two-yuan worth. When daily Beijing Times was presented, along with other newspapers, an official editorial denouncing the Southern Weekly tiff, the publisher and chief editor Dai Zigeng told Beijing municipal propaganda deputy Yan Liqiang to shove it. The editorial, originating with the Communist Party affiliated Global Times, offered a blunt threat, reported Asahi Shimbon (January 10). “Any media organization in China that confronts the government will end up being the loser.”

In the presence of Mr. Yan, according to inside sources quoted by Asahi Shimbon, Mr. Dai put the question to the assembled reporters and editors, who rejected the government editorial. “We will not carry the editorial,” announced Mr. Dai. “If you still insist that we carry it, I will resign my post.” The frustrated Mr. Yan left the meeting to phone up the printing plant, telling them to hold the press unless the editorial appeared. It did, finally, but on page 20 rather than the customary page 2. Another newspaper published the official editorial but placed it beside an ad for pest control, widely viewed as a statement. In the end, Mr. Dai did not resign.

Also appearing in the Beijing Times was a brief interesting piece on “porridge of the south,” explained the China Media Project (January 9). The Mandarin word for porridge sounds like the second character of weekly and a shorthand for Southern Weekly sounds like porridge of the south. “Hot porridge in an earthen pot, hailing from the southland,” said the translation. “Just set upon the table, the porridge still writhes with heat. Perhaps it still has a heart of courage. In the deep of the cold night, you open your mouth and white steam billows. There are so many cares in the world, and all you can count on for warmth is this bowl of porridge. A bowl of hot porridge tells us of the power of love and consolation.”

Media freedom as a concept differs considerably, West to East. Where civil and political rights – press and speech freedoms included – are enshrined as pillars to democracy and, thus, all things good a certain absolutism prevents debate. Beyond economic, social and cultural rights newer concepts differentiate communication rights along with employment, health care and education. Several governments have moved to enshrine internet access.

Much of the clamor played out in China on Sina Weibo, the hugely popular microblog site. It has nearly 400 million users. This is not lost on the Chinese government, which censored keywords last week including the name Southern Weekly. It’s one thing to order a newspaper to change or delete an article or column and quite another to bring social networks to heel.

Almost by coincidence Beijing was visited last week by Apple CEO Tim Cook and Google chairman Erik Schmidt. It was not for sightseeing; Beijing air pollution reaching highest ever levels. Google’s search market share in China has been in sharp decline since a censorship row but the prospect for mobile products, where Sina Weibo lives, is huge. Dr. Schmidt met with mobile app developers.

A year ago, Apple was forced to suspend retail iPhone4S sales after a near-riot in Beijing. Mr. Cook met this last week with China Mobile Chairman Xi Guohua, who has 700 million subscribers and no deal with Apple. Imagine the possibilities.


See also in ftm Knowledge

China and Media

For the media world China both entices and exasperates. Potentials in this youthful and rapidly developing country are huge. Yet media freedoms are far below world standards. This ftm Knowledge file peers over the Great Wall. Includes Resources 79 pages PDF (May 2012)

Order here

ftm resources



related ftm articles:

Memory Hole For Foreign News Bureaus
After years of shrinking foreign bureaus to save money, news organizations are finding more and more interest in their work. Maybe dismal economics hasn’t put globalization in reverse. Or maybe there are some trends you just can’t buck.

There’s A Riot Going On
Mobile devices are the trendy thing. For consumers, smartphones and tablets are fashion statements. For content producers they are the must-have platform. Will some have egg on their faces?

Strong Brands And Big Walls
Having a strong brand is good for business. The attributes are nurtured among the wise. Sometimes big brands smack into big walls.


advertisement


ftm Knowledge

Media in Spain - Diverse and Challenged – new

Media in Spain is steeped in tradition. yet challenged by diversity. Publishers hold great influence, broadcasters competing. New media has been slow to rise and business models for all are under stress. Rich in language and culture, Spain's media is reaching into the future and finding more than expected. 123 pages, PDF. January 2018

Order here

The Campaign Is On - Elections and Media

Elections campaigns are big media events. Candidates and issues are presented, analyzed and criticized in broadcast and print. Media is now more of a participant in elections than ever. This ftm Knowledge file reports on news coverage, advertising, endorsements and their effect on democracy at work. 84 pages. PDF (September 2017)

Order here

Fake News, Hate Speech and Propaganda

The institutional threat of fake news, hate speech and propaganda is testing the mettle of those who toil in news media. Those three related evils are not new, by any means, but taken together have put the truth and those reporting it on the back foot. Words matter. This ftm Knowledge file explores that light. 48 pages, PDF (March 2017)

Order here

More ftm Knowledge files here

Become an ftm Individual or Corporate Member to order Knowledge Files at no charge. JOIN HERE!

copyright ©2004-2014 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm