followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Big Business

The many faces of stagnation

In the front lines of the media world there’s no need for another expert reporting the obvious. Each week brings another irritatingly real story of causalities where media and money intersect. Big media is still big, says a new study; just a bit less so.

vortex stagnatingThe worlds biggest media companies are among the worlds most watched companies. To paraphrase American TV comedian David Letterman; There’s no business like media. There are a hundred like accounting.

The German media policy think tank IfM (Institut für Medien- und Kommunikationspolitik) released its annual report (April 29) on the 50 biggest media companies.The measure is gross receipts, gross revenue, turnover. In 2008 the gross receipts for those top 50 media companies was €360.88 billion, slightly lower than the figure for 2007 - €362.03 billion. In 2006 revenues for the top 50 media companies was estimated at €353.28 billion. The IfM says media revenue is stagnating. (See IfM Top 50 Ranking here

The top five of the big media companies are American; in order, Time Warner, Walt Disney, Comcast, News Corp and Viacom. Of those only News Corp increased revenue, the benefit from the Dow Jones / Wall Street Journal acquisition. And that’s a common theme. Acquisitions, few that there were, raised corporate revenues.

Similarly, Thompson Reuters moved from 13th place in the 2007 top 50 to 11th in 2008, increasing its revenue from €7.18 billion to €9.14 billion.

Some of those increasing revenue over 2007 levels did it the other way, selling something. Sixth place among the top 50 is Sony Entertainment, based in Tokyo. Sony’s 2008 revenue was €16.56 billion, up from €14.65 billion. Sony off-loaded Sony BMG to partner Bertelsmann. Sony moved up one ranking while Bertelsmann fell behind.

Bertelsmann is and continues to be Europe’s biggest media company, billing €16.11 billion in 2008. That’s down from €18.76 billion in 2007. Write offs from the Sony BMG and selling its North American book and DVD consumer division to Najafi Companies in July.

Time Warner, ranked number one in the world by revenues, will surely lose that lofty slot when it off-loads AOL sometime this year.

Vivendi is Europe’s second biggest media company, ranked 9th worldwide. It’s revenues grew to €11.295 billion in 2008 from €10.251 billion. Lagardère Media ranks third in Europe and 12th globally with revenues of €8.21 billion, down from 11th place and €8.58 billion. Reed Elsevier, with €6.6 billion revenues in 2008, ranked 4th in Europe and 16th overall.

Included in the IfM study are public and State broadcasters, a reminder that these, too, are media biggies. German public television network ARD ranked 5th biggest in Europe by revenue - €6.13 billion – and 17th worldwide. The BBC is ranked 7th in Europe with €5.54 billion revenue in 2008, ranking 19th in the world. Japan’s State broadcaster NHK ranks 27th in the world with €4.31 billion revenue. Italy’s public broadcaster RAI ranks 37th in the world with €3.21 billion revenue. France Télévisions, the French public broadcaster, ranked 43th with €2.93 billion revenue.

IfM project director Thomas Schnedler observed that revenues for public / State broadcasters and telecoms remained “relatively stable, in international comparison, through strategic partnerships and secure content.”

The biggest winners – those companies increasing revenue year to year – were US cable operator Liberty Media (27.3%), Thompson Reuters (27.2%), Sony Entertainment (13%), ProSiebenSat.1 (13%) and Grupo Prisa (10.5%). On the other end of that scale were ITV (-17.1%), Virgin Media (-16.2%), Gannett (-14.8%), Bertelsmann (-14.1%) and McGraw-Hill (-11.4%). Japanese network Nippon TV joined the big list and the New York Times Company departed. Of the 48 media companies ranked both in 2008 and 2007, 28 either increased or maintained revenue.

IfM Top 50 revenue“For the media conglomerates is not a normal economic crisis,” said IfM director Lutz Hachmeister, “explained by the savings rate of the advertising industry or consumer restraint. Rather, it is the coming technological change, economic upheaval and an identity crisis.”

If by “identity crisis” Herr Hachmeister means big media companies aren’t quite sure what business they’re in, he’s stating the obvious. The split between content producers and distributors is a widening trend; both, the stable ones at least, concentrating core strengths. Certainly, some publishers and some broadcasters are feeling the pain of new media and the “economic upheaval.”   But, too, being the biggest of the big media companies means changes come very slowly, a challenge as the next 50, 100 and 200 largest media companies can be far less stagnant.

 


related ftm articles:

The Incredible Shrinking British Media
Some corners of British media are gasping for air. Others are holding their breath. The oxygen is being sucked out.

German media's dark night
The German economy passed an unfortunate threshold, officially entering the recession zone. German media companies noticed, worried as ever, and moved into deeper restructuring. Some of it has been long in the planning and some not.

Media World Upheaval – Credit Crunch Hits Revenue Even More As Alternative Media Grows
There was a day last week when Media General’s shares actually closed up 111.3% higher than the day before ($8.66/$18.30) all because it announced that while its August results were still rotten, and no reason to believe the rest of the year will be any better, it was still the best month so far this year. Over at the New York Times, where they announced Internet revenue was up even though print revenues were awful, there was a 12% jump. So is everything all better now in newspaperland? Don’t you believe it!

Two Media Giants, One in the US The Other In The UK, Find the Traditional Media Financial Going Tough And The Digital Revenues Can’t Come In Fast Enough To Turn the Tide
Tribune, based in Chicago, announced its Internet traffic increased 28% in April over a year ago but that didn’t stop Moody’s from downgrading its long-term debt rating. In the UK, ITV1 has some of the best kick-off times for the upcoming World Cup and yet its advertising revenue for June and July is forecast to be well below a year ago. It is desperately looking at digital solutions to account for 50% of its total revenue by 2010.


advertisement

ftm resources


ftm Knowledge

Media in Spain - Diverse and Challenged – new

Media in Spain is steeped in tradition. yet challenged by diversity. Publishers hold great influence, broadcasters competing. New media has been slow to rise and business models for all are under stress. Rich in language and culture, Spain's media is reaching into the future and finding more than expected. 123 pages, PDF. January 2018

Order here

The Campaign Is On - Elections and Media

Elections campaigns are big media events. Candidates and issues are presented, analyzed and criticized in broadcast and print. Media is now more of a participant in elections than ever. This ftm Knowledge file reports on news coverage, advertising, endorsements and their effect on democracy at work. 84 pages. PDF (September 2017)

Order here

Fake News, Hate Speech and Propaganda

The institutional threat of fake news, hate speech and propaganda is testing the mettle of those who toil in news media. Those three related evils are not new, by any means, but taken together have put the truth and those reporting it on the back foot. Words matter. This ftm Knowledge file explores that light. 48 pages, PDF (March 2017)

Order here

More ftm Knowledge files here

Become an ftm Individual or Corporate Member to order Knowledge Files at no charge. JOIN HERE!

copyright ©2004-2010 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm